Ecotopia

the notebooks and reports of William Weston

181 pages

English language

Published Sept. 3, 1990

ISBN:
978-0-553-34847-7
Copied ISBN!
Goodreads:
550165

View on OpenLibrary

View on Inventaire

4 stars (2 reviews)

Ecotopia was founded when northern California, Oregon, and Washington seceded from the Union to create a “stable-state” ecosystem: the perfect balance between human beings and the environment. Now, twenty years later, this isolated, mysterious nation is welcoming its first officially sanctioned American visitor: New York Times-Post reporter Will Weston.

Skeptical yet curious about this green new world, Weston is determined to report his findings objectively. But from the start, he’s alternately impressed and unsettled by the laws governing Ecotopia’s earth-friendly agenda: energy-efficient “mini-cities” to eliminate urban sprawl, zero-tolerance pollution control, tree worship, ritual war games, and a woman-dominated government that has instituted such peaceful revolutions as the twenty-hour workweek and employee ownership of farms and businesses. His old beliefs challenged, his cynicism replaced by hope, Weston meets a sexually forthright Ecotopian woman and undertakes a relationship whose intensity will lead him to a critical choice between two worlds.

21 editions

reviewed Ecotopia by Ernest Callenbach

Enjoyable, but with a lot of whitewashing

3 stars

Overall I enjoyed Callenbach's visions of a hopeful future. A few things felt out of place to me though:

The first was the "war games" which just didn't quite fit with the rest of the society, in my mind. It's quite possible I'm just missing something, but I couldn't understand why they were included or what their place in the functioning of the society was supposed to be (as a vent for toxic masculinity to express itself so that it doesn't permeate into every day life, maybe? It seems like this could be done with less injury). They're also part of broader problematic appropriation of indigenous culture by the almost exclusively white cast (more on that in a bit) in the book in a way that feels a bit tropey, which I didn't love.

Similarly, there's a very out-of-place feeling chapter in the middle where he randomly says (paraphrasing): "and …

reviewed Écotopia by Ernest Callenbach

Enfin un imaginaire positif et écologique

5 stars

Est-ce ça la sobriété heureuse ? Des les années 1970, Callenbach propose un récit ambitieux d’un monde où les questions écologiques et sociales ont été prises à bras le corps par l’État.

Dans cette découverte de ce pays sécessionniste imaginaire on découvre un futur positif ou écologie ne veut pas dire privations. Si tout n’est pas parfait, Callenbach dessine un futur paisible ou protection de l’environnement et épanouissement des personnes vont de paire.

Le récit articulé entre « articles » de William Weston et notes de son journal intime offre un bon aperçu de la transition en soi nécessaire pour déconstruire la vision accumulatrice et matérialiste que l’on nous a inculqué. D’abord cynique et hautain, Weston s’ouvre peu à peu à la culture écotopienne et comprend les valeurs et intérêts défendus.

En 2023, alors que les imaginaires climatiques et écologiques sont souvent teintés de couleurs sombres, ce récit est utiles …